I'm sorry, I thought these screenshots would work according to the policies, since they all have:
720p quality at least;
proper source template;
no "extreme"(?) closeups (imho?);
a depiction of the character's most typical and recognizable likeness (should have I sticked to one likeness for Jeremiah, maybe? Ain't he and Nygma examples of characters with alteregos (Ed/Riddler, Jeremiah/Mr. J) as the infobox template suggested?);
And I haven't seen any trace of a past consensus? So, I can't see what exactly the problem is. What do you mean by "we"? Cause I haven't seen anywhere if the admins are the only ones allowed to change them?
I don't mean to be rude, I just ask for clarification.
Might I change Mr. J's pic for this one then? Cause the current one's got a frankly awful compostion and poor quality: off-centered, a bit too far I think, and his facial features aren't that visible from that angle.
I agree. The new Mr. J pic on the main page is off-centered since you can see black on the bottom, showing the photo doesn't have the right measurements for the image. It's just off and the picture Rwo had looks much more fitting.